Critics dispute California governor's claim of decreased crime

Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

(The Center Square) - Gov. Gavin Newsom is touting new crime data showing declines throughout California, though critics and law enforcement officials argue the numbers don't reflect reality.


According to Newsom’s office, violent crime fell 6.3% and homicides dropped 11.9% across nine major California jurisdictions during the first nine months of 2026 compared to the same period in 2025. The office cited figures from the Major Cities Chiefs Association.


The governor’s office pointed to steep drops in several cities over that timeframe, including a 44% decline in homicides and a 15% drop in violent crime in Sacramento. Oakland saw homicides fall 22% and violent crime decrease 19%, while homicides dropped 30% in the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department’s jurisdiction and 13% in the city of Los Angeles.


Newsom’s administration attributed the decrease in crime to more than $2.1 billion in state public safety investments since 2019, expanded California Highway Patrol enforcement teams, gun control laws and fentanyl interdiction efforts.


“California is making real progress in reducing violent crime and making our communities safer,” Newsom said in a press release. “These results are no accident – they reflect our sustained investment in public safety and strong partnership with local law enforcement.”


Newsom, whose office said was unavailable for an interview with The Center Square, went on to say that the work is far from over.


“The investments and partnerships we’ve strengthened are laying the foundation for lasting progress – equipping law enforcement with the tools and resources to prevent violence, hold offenders accountable and keep California safe for years to come,” said Newsom, who is considering a run for president in 2028.


Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco, a Republican who ran unsuccessfully for governor this year, pushed back on Newsom’s narrative, arguing that Californians are not seeing a safer state and accusing lawmakers of altering how offenses are classified.


"Speaking for sheriffs, chiefs of police and law enforcement officers across our state, I can loudly say that all of us wish we had the support of state government, including Governor Newsom, when it comes to fighting crime," Bianco told The Center Square in an email. "Ask a resident if they feel crime is down in California! It is not.”


Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco

Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco is president of the California State Sheriffs Association. Photo: Riverside County Sheriff's Office / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain


“If you want to know the truth about the state of public safety, ask a law enforcement officer, not a disingenuous politician looking to con you for his next election,” said Bianco.


Los Angeles County Republican Party Chair Roxanne Hoge echoed Bianco’s skepticism regarding how crime is tracked and prosecuted in the state.


"When you redefine crime [and] you don’t prosecute crime, then, yes, crime will go down,” Hoge told The Center Square via email. 


But Newsom’s office pointed to longer-term statewide trends, noting that California’s 2025 homicide rate fell to 3.5 per 100,000 residents — its lowest level since tracking began in 1966. The office also said statewide rates for homicide, robbery and property crime have dropped significantly since 2019.


Among the initiatives credited by the administration are $350 million in community violence intervention grants, the hiring of 1,000 additional California Highway Patrol officers and over $242 million in grants to local agencies to combat organized retail theft.


Republicans and others have criticized Newsom for failing to fund Proposition 36, the voter-approved measure that increases penalties for certain theft and drug-related charges. Newsom has responded to that criticism by saying that the state is not the only source of funding and that counties and cities should step up and spend money.

 

Salem News Channel Today

Sponsored Links

On Air & Up Next

  • The Hugh Hewitt Show
    9:00PM - 12:00AM
     
    Hugh Hewitt is one of the nation’s leading bloggers and a genuine media   >>
     
  • The Kevin Jackson Show
    12:00AM - 2:00AM
     
    The Kevin Jackson Show is a nationally syndicated Conservative talk-radio show   >>
     
  • Kyle Warren
    2:00AM - 6:00AM
    Kyle Warren
    949-822-7959
     
    Kyle Warren is talking about the news and information you’re not getting from   >>
     

See the Full Program Guide